After whipping up a delicious steak dinner, you may have chosen to let the baked potatoes cool on the counter before placing them in the fridge, then forget about them until you walk into the kitchen the next morning. Now, are they spoiled or are they still edible?
You should never eat baked potatoes that have been left out on the counter overnight. They should be refrigerated after no more than two hours at room temperature. Any longer than that, you risk foodborne illness and suffer the consequences.
If you accidentally left your baked potatoes out on the counter overnight, they should be thrown out right away. They are not worth the risk of potentially getting sick. Fortunately, potatoes are fairly inexpensive, and you can make a new batch if you want to enjoy them again the next day.
Can you get food poisoning from baked potatoes?
Like anything else, you can get food poisoning from a rotten baked potato. If left too long, baked potatoes can potentially form botulism – which can be fatal in certain circumstances.
To be on the safe side, you always want to store your leftovers properly. This means getting them to the coldest temperature in the refrigerator quickly and not leaving them out at room temperature for an extended period of time.
It is more common for baked potatoes to become more dangerous if they are left in their tightly wrapped foil wrappers. This is because oxygen cannot reach the potato, which can speed up germination and the spread of bacteria.
If you think your baked potato is gone, throw it away right away. In case you have already eaten it before realizing that it has spoiled, discard it and watch for any symptoms that may arise.
You may feel discomfort in your abdomen and chills throughout your body. If you develop a high fever, it is recommended that you contact your doctor for medical advice. Other than that, drink plenty of fluids and rest to give your body a chance to fight off the infection.
How do you know if a baked potato has gone bad?
One of the clearest signs that a baked potato has gone bad is mold growth. If you see visible mold on the top of the potato, throw it away immediately. Once you’ve cut the potato, you may see discoloration and signs of possible mold, which also means you should throw it away.
If you added seasonings to the potato to make it a baked potato, you may need to take a closer look. Some ingredients can go moldy more quickly, like cheese or sour cream.
As always, you should inspect food scraps before consuming them. If there is any sort of unpleasant odor once you open the container, it’s a likely sign that your food has gone bad or is in the process of going bad. Trust your gut on this one, as it’s often right when it comes to food.
Baked potatoes should be softer after baking, but if they get too soft, they are no longer good to eat. By doing a quick eye exam and smell test, you can eat your potato with confidence that it will be good.
How to store potatoes in the oven?
Baked potatoes are often cooked wrapped in foil. When you are going to store leftover potatoes, you will want to uncover them and store them in a plastic container or container. Always let potatoes cool completely before refrigerating.
Another option would be to store leftover baked potatoes in Ziploc brand plastic bags. This is the ideal method if you are going to store several, since it will not take up much space in the fridge.
Once the potatoes have cooled, you’ll want to put them away quickly. Leaving potatoes in the oven on the counter for more than two hours can give them time to grow bacteria and spoil.
Depending on the ingredients with which you have decorated your baked potatoes, they can last from 2 to 5 days in the refrigerator. If you know ahead of time that you won’t be eating them right away, leave the toppings alone and leave the baked potatoes alone.
Whichever method you choose to store your potatoes, you need to make sure they are airtight. Any air that gets into the container can speed up the spoiling process of leftovers, and no one wants a wasted baked potato.
How long can you keep potatoes in the oven?
Depending on how you choose to store your potatoes in the oven, refrigerator, or freezer, they will keep anywhere from 2 days to 6 months. Frozen potato is not always the best option as it loses its texture, but it is an option.
If you keep your potatoes well sealed, they will last as long as possible. Eventually it all goes wrong, though, so you’ll want to keep an eye out for them in your fridge.
When making a larger batch of baked potatoes, it can be a good idea to plan meals around the side dish. Be sure to have dinner menus that incorporate potatoes for the next two nights so you can access leftovers before they lose their freshness.
Some people find it helpful to label and date containers so they know exactly when to put leftovers in the refrigerator. This shows you what to eat first, so you don’t spoil yourself without realizing how long it’s been in the fridge.
If you have left the potatoes out on the counter for 2 hours or more, you will need to proceed with caution. Even if they still look good, they are more likely to deteriorate faster. Try to eat the potato in a day or two.
Once refrigerated, you will have to reheat them when you want to eat them. You should never reheat your potato in the oven and then store it in the refrigerator. This ensures that the potato loses its overall quality and texture.
Can you reheat potatoes in the oven?
When reheating potatoes in the oven, you have several options. You can microwave them, heat them in the oven, place them in a pan on the stove, or even grill them! Baked potatoes are almost as delicious reheated as they were fresh.
If you originally baked your potatoes in the oven, it would naturally make sense to put them back in the oven to reheat. You can even put the grill on for a few minutes to keep the cheese crisp and melted again.
Microwaving leftover potatoes can slightly affect the texture, resulting in a softer baked potato. However, it is the fastest method and makes for a quick and easy mid-day meal.
For the stovetop method, you can lightly oil a skillet and place the cooked potato on the preheated surface. Cover the pan with a lid to allow the top of the potato to heat evenly, then you are ready to enjoy your now slightly crispy potato on the bottom.
If you’re already firing up the grill, simply wrap leftover baked potatoes in foil and place on grill. After several minutes, it will have warmed up nicely and you can carefully unwrap the foil before digging.
With so many options for reheating leftover potatoes, there’s no reason you can’t enjoy them for days at a time. If you’ve brought home leftovers from a restaurant, enjoy them quickly because you can’t be sure how long they’ll be gone.
Sharing is showing interest!